Skip to Content
Horn Wright, LLP Horn Wright, LLP
855-465-4622
Top

What to Do If You Hit a Parked Car

A black sedan with significant damage to the driver's side door, parked on a city street next to a curb and sidewalk.
|

What to Do If You Hit a Parked Car

Just Hit a Parked Car in NYC? Take a Breath. We’ve Got You. 

It’s a typical day in the city. Maybe you're squeezing into a tight space or navigating a narrow block. Suddenly, bump. Your heart skips. You just tapped a parked car. And now you're panicking. What do you do? 

First, know this: it happens. With crowded streets, tight lanes, and endless distractions, New York’s roads aren’t exactly forgiving. But if you stay calm and take the right steps, it’s entirely manageable. And if things get more complicated than expected? Horn Wright, LLP, has your back. Our car accident attorneys know the ins and outs of New York’s traffic laws and can help if this turns into something bigger than a parking mishap. 

Pause, Breathe, and Take Control 

Take a breath. Seriously. Even minor accidents spike your adrenaline, but reacting with a clear head makes all the difference. The moment you realize you hit a parked car, pull over as safely as possible. Avoid double-parking or blocking traffic if you can, and turn on your hazard lights so other drivers know something’s going on. Then, quickly check yourself for injuries. Even in a low-speed impact, it’s not unusual to feel shaken or sore. 

Now take a look at the damage. Did you just nudge the bumper? Crack a mirror? Or is it a deeper scrape that may cost more to fix? Either way, don’t downplay it or assume it’s "nothing." You'll want proof of what happened from the start. Insurance companies love to take advantage of car accident victims. 

Immediate Actions You Absolutely Can’t Skip 

Tempted to Drive Away? Don't Even Think About It. 

You might be panicking and thinking about just leaving. Don’t. In New York, driving away after hitting a parked car (even if the damage seems small) can be considered a hit-and-run. And yes, that’s a crime. It’s taken seriously by both the NYPD and insurance companies. 

Here’s what you absolutely must do: 

  • Leave your name, phone number, and insurance details in a visible, secure spot on the car. A simple note under the windshield wiper works if you can’t find the owner. 
  • Snap photos and videos of the damage. Capture your vehicle’s position and surroundings too. 

You’ll also want to make note of exactly where it happened. Whether you're near the Williamsburg Bridge, parked beside Central Park, or pulled over by Yankee Stadium, mark the location clearly in your records. These small steps go a long way in protecting you from exaggerated claims later. 

NYPD: Friend or Foe? When You Actually Need to Call 

Let’s be honest. Nobody loves calling the police after a fender bender. But sometimes, it’s not just the smart choice. It’s the law. In New York, you're required to notify the NYPD if the damage is $1,000 or more or if you can’t find the car’s owner after a reasonable effort. 

Getting a police report might feel like overkill, but it can work in your favor. It creates an official record of the incident, which helps your insurance company assess what really happened. And if the other driver tries to stretch the truth later, you’ll have something objective to refer to. 

Protect Yourself: Information is Your Shield 

You’re rattled. That’s normal. But missing key details in this moment can leave you vulnerable. So slow down and document everything you can. 

Here’s what to gather: 

  • The vehicle's make, model, color, and license plate number. 
  • Witness names and any visible security cameras nearby. 

You should also take personal notes while everything’s fresh. Write down how fast you were going, where you were, and what you saw. Was the car illegally parked? Was visibility limited? These notes will help later if your memory fades or if there’s any dispute about what happened. 

Talking to Insurance: Your Next Big Move 

Insurance Calls? Less Painful Than You Think. 

Once you’ve taken care of the scene, your next step is calling your insurance provider. Yes, even if the damage looks minor. Reporting it quickly helps avoid penalties and keeps you in good standing. 

When you speak with them, stick to the facts. Share where the incident happened and what steps you took. Don’t assume blame before the full story is reviewed. If you’ve already filed a police report, let your insurer know, they may need a copy. The goal is to stay transparent without overexplaining or making assumptions. 

If the vehicle owner contacts your insurance later, you’ll be glad you handled things early and properly especially if insurance isn’t enough to pay for the totaled car. 

Liability Explained: How Much Trouble Could You Be In? 

Worried about being labeled the "bad guy"? It's not always that black and white. New York follows a comparative negligence system. That means even if you’re partly responsible, the law looks at how much fault you share and adjusts accordingly. 

If the parked car was in an illegal spot (blocking a hydrant or sticking into an intersection) that could shift some of the responsibility away from you. But if it was parked correctly and you just misjudged your turn, you’ll likely take the full blame. Either way, it doesn’t automatically mean criminal charges or financial ruin. It just means you’ll need to be honest, thorough, and possibly prepared for higher insurance rates. 

Mistakes You'll Definitely Want to Dodge 

You followed all the steps, or so you think. But small errors can spiral. One big mistake is leaving a note with no contact information or one that’s illegible. That’s as bad as leaving no note at all. Another misstep is posting about the accident on social media. You might think it's harmless, but those words or images could come back to bite you. 

Here are key errors to watch out for: 

  • Leaving incomplete or unclear information. 
  • Skipping NYC's DMV reporting if damages exceed $1,000. 

Your best bet? Keep the details offline, file all necessary reports, and hold onto your notes and photos. 

Can’t Find the Owner? Here's Exactly What to Do 

You looked around. Knocked on nearby doors. Waited a few minutes. Still no sign of the owner? Don’t assume you can just walk away. Even if the damage seems small, you still have legal responsibilities. 

Leave a detailed note with your name, phone number, and what happened. Be specific but brief. If the damage looks serious or you’re unsure, call the NYPD and make an official report. It might feel excessive, but it shows that you’re handling the situation responsibly. 

Take photos of the note in place and the car’s condition. Document your efforts to locate the owner, such as asking nearby businesses if they saw anything or checking if the car had a local permit. These details help prove that you acted in good faith. 

From Panic to Peace: Your NYC Accident Survival Guide 

Accidents like these can turn a calm afternoon into a stressful mess. But you’re not alone, and you’re definitely not helpless. When you hit a parked car in New York, the best thing you can do is act quickly, document everything, and stay accountable. 

Remember: 

  • Stop, breathe, and assess. 
  • Leave your info, take photos, and call the police when needed. 
  • Protect yourself with documentation and early insurance communication. 

No one plans to be in these situations, but with the right steps, you can handle it like a pro. 

Horn Wright, LLP Has Your Back—Always 

At Horn Wright, LLP, we know how overwhelming even a minor accident can feel, especially in a city like New York where the rules move as fast as the traffic. Our team brings not only legal experience but real empathy. We’ve helped countless New Yorkers through confusing insurance claims, damage disputes, and legal questions that come up when you hit a parked car.  

Contact our offices today for a FREE consultation. 

Categories: